Benefits of SMSF vs Retail Super Funds: Understanding the Advantages of a Self-Managed Super Fund

This article outlines the main benefits of SMSFs and contrasts them against the features of retail super funds to help you understand the key differences.

Introduction

A Self-Managed Super Fund (SMSF) offers Australians the ability to take greater control over their retirement savings compared to traditional superannuation funds. While not suitable for everyone, the benefits of SMSF structures are often highlighted in terms of flexibility, investment choice, and potential tax advantages.

Control Over Your Retirement Savings

One of the most widely discussed benefits of SMSF is control. Trustees of an SMSF make all the decisions about how the fund operates and how assets are invested. Whether it’s shares, term deposits, managed funds, or property, control lies directly with the trustees themselves. This contrasts with retail super funds, where investment choices are generally limited to pre-set portfolios managed by the fund provider.

Wider Range of Investment Options

SMSFs offer a broader spectrum of investment opportunities. Trustees can consider direct property investment, listed securities, managed funds, and even borrowing for certain assets through limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBAs). By contrast, retail super funds typically limit members to managed investment pools, which may not offer the same flexibility or direct ownership of assets.

Flexibility in Strategy and Retirement Income

SMSFs provide flexibility that allows members to adapt strategies as circumstances change. Trustees can decide when to buy or sell assets, when to take retirement income, and how benefits are distributed. For example, members may choose to receive benefits as a pension, lump sum, or a combination of both. In retail funds, income streams and payout options are often more rigid and governed by fund rules.

Pooling Family Superannuation in an SMSF

Pooling Family Superannuation

An SMSF can have up to six members, often making it a popular choice for families who wish to pool their superannuation balances. This pooling may allow for the purchase of larger investments, such as property, which may not be accessible within a retail super fund structure. Retail funds, on the other hand, keep member accounts separate and do not offer pooled family investment opportunities.

Potential Tax Advantages

Like all superannuation funds, SMSFs benefit from concessional tax treatment. Income is generally taxed at 15%, and capital gains on assets held longer than 12 months may attract a reduced effective rate. Trustees also have the ability to time the sale of assets to manage tax outcomes, which is not possible in a retail super structure where decisions are made centrally. In retirement, income streams from SMSFs can be tax-free, similar to other super funds, but with greater flexibility in how benefits are structured.

Asset Protection Considerations

In some circumstances, SMSF assets may receive protection from creditors in the event of bankruptcy. This can provide additional peace of mind for members who want their retirement savings insulated from personal financial risks. Retail super funds also offer asset protection under superannuation law, though SMSFs provide members direct oversight of how their fund is structured.

Low and Transparent Fees

SMSFs often operate with a fixed-fee structure for administration and compliance, which can be cost-effective for higher balances. Retail super funds generally charge fees based on a percentage of the balance, which can add up as balances grow. However, it is worth noting that SMSFs also carry costs for professional advice, audits, and administration, which may not suit smaller balances.

Is an SMSF Right for You?

The benefits of SMSF can be significant when compared with retail funds, particularly for those who value control, flexibility, and broader investment choice. However, trustees take on responsibility for compliance, reporting, and decision-making, which may not appeal to everyone. For this reason, before setting up an SMSF, it is important to consult with licensed professionals such as accountants, financial planners, or legal experts to assess whether an SMSF is suitable for your circumstances.

---

UNDERSTAND THE SMSF JOURNEY

Every SMSF journey is unique. Connect with our team to explore SMSF considerations and understand how different professionals may fit into the process.

EXPLORE YOUR SMSF OPTIONS >

(GENERAL INFORMATION ONLY)

---

DISCLAIMER: This article is provided for general information and educational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, legal, tax, investment, or other professional advice and has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. This article may include perspectives from industry contributors. Contributor participation does not imply endorsement, recommendation, or preferred referral status. While reasonable care has been taken in preparing this content, no representation or warranty is made as to its accuracy, completeness, or currency. SMSF Intelligence does not accept liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this information or any linked materials. SMSF Intelligence does not provide financial, legal, or tax advice. Before making any decisions, you should consider the appropriateness of the information in light of your circumstances and seek advice from a suitably qualified and licensed professional.